--- title: "Blues Ordered To Stop \"Most Favored Nation\" Contracts" description: Beginning in Feb. 2013, Most Favored Nation clauses can no longer be included in facility or provider agreements image: https://www.mbrbilling.com/hs-fs/file-16605124-png/images/insurance_monopoly-resized-600.png --- [![](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hs-fs/hubfs/MBR-Images/logo.png?width=340&name=logo.png)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/) - [Home](https://www.mbrbilling.com/) - [Client Login](http://clientlogin.mbrbilling.com/) - [Contact Us](https://www.mbrbilling.com/contact-us) SEARCH # Medical Billing Blog # Blues Ordered To Stop "Most Favored Nation" Contracts Posted by [Barry Shatzman](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/author/barry-shatzman) on Thu, Sep, 06, 2012 @ 15:09 PM - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ![BCBSM Most Favored Nation Clauses May Violate Antitrust Laws](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hs-fs/file-16605124-png/images/insurance_monopoly-resized-600.png?width=158&height=146&name=insurance_monopoly-resized-600.png)The United States Department of Justice (“DOJ”) and the State of Michigan filed suit on October 18, 2010 against Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (BCBSM).  The DOJ alleges that BCBSM’s use of “Most Favored Nation” clauses in its contracts with hospitals and providers inMichiganis anticompetitive.  These preferential pricing policies, known in the hospital and insurance industries as “most favored nation” clauses typically require that BCBSM receive the lowest rates the participating providers and/or hospitals offer.  Participating providers and/or hospitals are then required to charge any competing plan an agreed percentage above the rate provided to BCBSM.  The DOJ alleges BCBSM has “Most Favored Nation” contracts with at least 70 of Michigan’s 131 general acute care hospitals.  The complaint further alleges that BCBSM also reduced payments to smaller hospitals that declined to enter into agreements with “Most Favored Nation” clauses.  The DOJ claims that “Most Favored Nation” clauses give BCBSM an unlawful competitive advantage, resulting in higher prices to consumers in violation of the Sherman Act as well as the Michigan Antitrust Reform Act.  The Sherman Act of 1890 attempted to outlaw the restriction of competition by large companies, and the Michigan Antitrust Reform Act of 1984, which was an act to prohibit contracts, combinations, and conspiracies in restraint of trade or commerce. In response to this litigation, Michigan Insurance Commissioner Kevin Clinton issued an order on July 18 saying that the State of Michigan will no longer allow the use of “Most Favored Nation” policies by insurers, effective February 1, 2013.  It remains to be seen how this declaration will affect the actual application of Most Favored Nation clauses in facility and provider participation agreements, and much more needs to be done to clarify exactly what constitutes a MFN clause and how it affects contracts currently in force.  But it’s a start, and the order was supported by The Michigan Association of Health Plans, who released a statement on July 20, which began, "These orders will help create a more competitive market for health insurance in Michigan and are a start toward leveling a playing field that has been tipped toward Blue Cross for many years." *image from opencongress.org ### Subscribe via Email [![](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hs-fs/file-16642138-png/images/bg/facebook.png)](https://www.facebook.com/MedBillResources) [![](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hs-fs/file-16650079-png/images/bg/twitter.png)](https://twitter.com/#!/MedBillResource) [![](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hs-fs/file-16643229-png/images/bg/linkedin.png)](http://www.linkedin.com/company/medical-billing-resources) [![](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hs-fs/file-16646680-png/images/bg/rss.png)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/CMS/UI/Modules/BizBlogger/rss.aspx?tabid=484940&moduleid=1043750&maxcount=25&u=107101&t=BBE4D262E126601B3B04C3F46C38B13F) [![New Call-to-Action](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/119723/112e1d48-db0d-4713-be81-8744e7438136.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/119723/112e1d48-db0d-4713-be81-8744e7438136) [![Click me](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/119723/73857c0b-bb42-4989-9f2b-6f01b79dda8d.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/119723/73857c0b-bb42-4989-9f2b-6f01b79dda8d) [![worksheet](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/119723/e4db838f-b08e-4fb6-bce4-c965b078dce1.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/119723/e4db838f-b08e-4fb6-bce4-c965b078dce1)     ### Latest Posts ### Browse by Tag - [$75 million (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/75-million) - [2014 (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/2014) - [2015 (5)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/2015) - [21st Century Cures Act (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/21st-century-cures-act) - [340B drug pricing program (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/340b-drug-pricing-program) - [59 modifier (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/59-modifier) - [90 day wait period (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/90-day-wait-period) - [abuse (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/abuse) - [ACA (42)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/aca) - [ACA, Health Law, Repeal, GOP (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/aca-health-law-repeal-gop) - [access (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/access) - [Affordable Care Act (54)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/affordable-care-act) - [Alternative Payment Model (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/alternative-payment-model) - [AMA (6)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/ama) - [Ambulatory Payment Classifications (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/ambulatory-payment-classifications) - [annual notice (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/annual-notice) - [annual report (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/annual-report) - [Anthem (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/anthem) - [anti-kickback (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/anti-kickback) - [APM (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/apm) - [Audits (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/audits) - [Balance Billing (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/balance-billing) - [Balanced Budget Act (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/balanced-budget-act) - [Bankruptcy (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/bankruptcy) - [Baucus (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/baucus) - [BCBSMI (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/bcbsmi) - [Beneficiary Access (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/beneficiary-access) - [Bernard Sanders (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/bernard-sanders) - [billing (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/billing) - [billing, medical billing companies (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/billing-medical-billing-companies) - [Blue Cross Blue Shield (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/blue-cross-blue-shield) - [Bronze Plans (4)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/bronze-plans) - [budget (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/budget) - [bundled payments (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/bundled-payments) - [Canceling policies (5)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/canceling-policies) - [Cardiac Rehabilitation Incentive Payment Model (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cardiac-rehabilitation-incentive-payment-model) - [Cardiology Billing (13)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cardiology-billing) - [CBO (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cbo) - [CEHRT (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cehrt) - [Certified EHR Technologies (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/certified-ehr-technologies) - [chart review (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/chart-review) - [CHIP (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/chip) - [Chronic Care Management (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/chronic-care-management) - [Cigna (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cigna) - [claims processing (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/claims-processing) - [CMS (49)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cms) - [CMS requirements (11)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cms-requirements) - [CMS, Final Rule, Quality Payment Program, Medicare (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cms-final-rule-quality-payment-program-medicare) - [CMS-1500 (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cms-1500) - [co-payment (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/co-payment) - [Cobra (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cobra) - [Coburn (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/coburn) - [coding (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/coding) - [Commonwealth Fund (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/commonwealth-fund) - [Compliance (49)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/compliance) - [Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/comprehensive-care-for-joint-replacement) - [congress (5)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/congress) - [Congressional Leadership (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/congressional-leadership) - [Consumer costs (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/consumer-costs) - [conversion factor (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/conversion-factor) - [coronavirus (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/coronavirus) - [cost (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cost) - [cost savings (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cost-savings) - [costs (4)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/costs) - [coverage (12)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/coverage) - [covid-19 (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/covid-19) - [CPT (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/cpt) - [deductible (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/deductible) - [Delay (8)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/delay) - [Department of Labor (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/department-of-labor) - [Department of Veteran Affairs (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/department-of-veteran-affairs) - [Dermatology Billing (11)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/dermatology-billing) - [Detroit (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/detroit) - [diagnosis (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/diagnosis) - [Dingell (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/dingell) - [disclosure (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/disclosure) - [Doc Causus (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/doc-causus) - [doc fix (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/doc-fix) - [Doctors (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/doctors) - [documentation (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/documentation) - [DOJ (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/doj) - [DOL (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/dol) - [donut hole (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/donut-hole) - [DRG (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/drg) - [Drug Benefit (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/drug-benefit) - [drug discount (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/drug-discount) - [E/M (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/e-m) - [Early Retiree Reinsurance Program (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/early-retiree-reinsurance-program) - [EDI (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/edi) - [efficiency (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/efficiency) - [EHR (10)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/ehr) - [EHR Incentive Program (5)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/ehr-incentive-program) - [EHR Payment Adjustments (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/ehr-payment-adjustments) - [Electronic Data Interchange (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/electronic-data-interchange) - [electronic health records (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/electronic-health-records) - [electronic medical records (4)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/electronic-medical-records) - [Eligible Clinicians (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/eligible-clinicians) - [Employer Mandate (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/employer-mandate) - [EMR (14)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/emr) - [enrollment (4)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/enrollment) - [EP (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/ep) - [equity (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/equity) - [ERRP (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/errp) - [Exemption 6 (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/exemption-6) - [family health insurance (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/family-health-insurance) - [FDA (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/fda) - [federal court (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/federal-court) - [fee (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/fee) - [fee for service (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/fee-for-service) - [final rule (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/final-rule) - [final version (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/final-version) - [fiscal impact (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/fiscal-impact) - [flat rate (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/flat-rate) - [FOIA (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/foia) - [Fraud (10)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/fraud) - [GAO (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/gao) - [Gold Plans (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/gold-plans) - [Government shutdown (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/government-shutdown) - [Grandfathering (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/grandfathering) - [Group Practice Reporting Option (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/group-practice-reporting-option) - [GRPO (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/grpo) - [GT modifier (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/gt-modifier) - [Hardship (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hardship) - [hardship exemption (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hardship-exemption) - [Harkin (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/harkin) - [health and human services (4)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/health-and-human-services) - [Health care (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/health-care) - [health information exchange (22)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/health-information-exchange) - [Health Insurance (21)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/health-insurance) - [Health Plan (21)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/health-plan) - [health plans (6)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/health-plans) - [health reform (30)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/health-reform) - [Health Savings Accounts (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/health-savings-accounts) - [health services (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/health-services) - [healthcare (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/healthcare) - [healthcare costs (14)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/healthcare-costs) - [healthcare history (6)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/healthcare-history) - [Healthcare.gov (27)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/healthcare-gov) - [Healthy Michigan Plan (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/healthy-michigan-plan) - [HHS (9)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hhs) - [high-deductible (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/high-deductible) - [HIPAA (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hipaa) - [HITECH (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hitech) - [home health care (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/home-health-care) - [Hospital (4)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hospital) - [hospital employment (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hospital-employment) - [Hospital Insurance Trust Fund (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hospital-insurance-trust-fund) - [Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Program (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hospital-value-based-purchasing-program) - [House Energy and Commerce Committee (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/house-energy-and-commerce-committee) - [House Ways and Means Committee (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/house-ways-and-means-committee) - [HSA (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/hsa) - [ICD-10 (24)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/icd-10) - [ICD-9 (8)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/icd-9) - [IFR (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/ifr) - [IG Report (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/ig-report) - [improper payment (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/improper-payment) - [improper payments (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/improper-payments) - [improved cash flow (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/improved-cash-flow) - [improvement (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/improvement) - [Incentive payments (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/incentive-payments) - [incentives (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/incentives) - [Increase Medical Billing Revenue (5)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/increase-medical-billing-revenue) - [Individual Eligible Professional (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/individual-eligible-professional) - [Individual Eligible Professionals (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/individual-eligible-professionals) - [individual health insurance (16)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/individual-health-insurance) - [individual market (9)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/individual-market) - [Inpatient Rehabilitation Facilities (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/inpatient-rehabilitation-facilities) - [insurance (4)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/insurance) - [Insurance company (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/insurance-company) - [Interim Final Rule (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/interim-final-rule) - [IRS (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/irs) - [Kathleen Sebelius (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/kathleen-sebelius) - [kickbacks (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/kickbacks) - [King v Burwell (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/king-v-burwell) - [Laboratory (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/laboratory) - [listserv (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/listserv) - [local healthcare expenditures (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/local-healthcare-expenditures) - [lockbox (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/lockbox) - [MACRA (7)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/macra) - [MACRA, Fee for Service, Physician Pay (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/macra-fee-for-service-physician-pay) - [MACs (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/macs) - [March 31 (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/march-31) - [Meaningful Use (11)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/meaningful-use) - [Meaningful Use 2 (7)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/meaningful-use-2) - [Meaningful Use 3 (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/meaningful-use-3) - [Medicaid (8)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medicaid) - [Medicaid expansion (6)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medicaid-expansion) - [Medical Billing Companies (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medical-billing-companies) - [medical billing compliance (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medical-billing-compliance) - [Medical Billing Fraud (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medical-billing-fraud) - [Medical Billing Services (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medical-billing-services) - [medical necessity (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medical-necessity) - [medical practice (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medical-practice) - [Medicare (42)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medicare) - [Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act (1)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medicare-access-and-chip-reauthorization-act) - [Medicare Advantage (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medicare-advantage) - [medicare cut (11)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medicare-cut) - [Medicare Data (3)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medicare-data) - [Medicare EHR Incentive Program (2)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medicare-ehr-incentive-program) - [Medicare fraud (5)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/blog/topic/medicare-fraud) - [Home](https://www.mbrbilling.com/) - [Why MBR?](https://www.mbrbilling.com/why-mbr/) - [Resource Center](https://www.mbrbilling.com/resource-center/) - [About MBR](https://www.mbrbilling.com/about-mbr/) - [Client Login](http://clientlogin.mbrbilling.com/) Connect with us! [![](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hubfs/MBR-Images/facebook.png)](https://www.facebook.com/MedBillResources) [![](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hubfs/MBR-Images/twitter.png)](https://twitter.com/#!/MedBillResource) [![](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hubfs/MBR-Images/linkedin.png)](http://www.linkedin.com/company/medical-billing-resources) [![](https://www.mbrbilling.com/hubfs/MBR-Images/rss.png)](https://www.mbrbilling.com/CMS/UI/Modules/BizBlogger/rss.aspx?tabid=484940&moduleid=1043750&maxcount=25&u=107101&t=BBE4D262E126601B3B04C3F46C38B13F) © 2012 Medical Billing Resources - All Rights Reserved 28237 Orchard Lake Road, Suite 100 | Farmington Hills, MI 48334 | Local: 248.932.2607 | Toll Free: 800-895-9563 | Fax: 248-932-2863